Two gay men standing head-to-head in a romantic and full of tension pose.

Paweł from Wink3r

Added: 15 listopada 2026

Am I Gay? My First Time with a Man

In the US, 7.3% of men aged 18-49 reported sexual activity with another man. In the UK, 5.5% of respondents had genital contact with a man, while only 2.5% identified as gay or bisexual. One experience does not define your orientation.

AITwo adult men in shirts sitting on a couch, the older one gently lifting the younger one's shirt, and the younger one enjoys it

In a US government household survey, the National Survey of Family Growth, 7.3% of men aged 18-49 reported between 2017 and 2019 that they had had sexual contact with another man in their lifetime. Meanwhile, the British representative study Natsal-3 from 2010-2012 provides further data: 5.5% of men aged 16-74 had ever had genital contact with another man, whereas 2.5% identified as gay or bisexual. The answer to the question "am I gay" is not decided after a single night. It depends on a long-term pattern of desire, which only becomes clear once the initial stress subsides.

Importantly, among British men who have had such genital contact, as many as 59.5% described their orientation as heterosexual. In light of this data, a one-time sexual experience and psychosexual identity are two completely separate categories.

How Many Men Have Already Had This Experience?

The questions in both studies were phrased differently, which is why the results, differing by a few percentage points, do not measure the exact same phenomenon. The American statistic reaching 7.3% covers any sexual activity with another man. The British analysis, on the other hand, includes only sex involving genital contact: oral, anal, or other direct touching of the genitals. Kissing without such contact is not counted in the mentioned 5.5%.

StudyStudied groupMeasured indicatorPercentage
NSFG, USA, 2017-2019men aged 18-49any sexual activity with a man (ever)7.3%
NSFG, USA, 2017-2019men aged 18-49any sexual activity with a man (last 12 months)3.2%
Natsal-3, UK, 2010-2012men aged 16-74genital contact with a man (ever)5.5%
Natsal-3men aged 16-74any same-sex attraction6.5%
Natsal-3men aged 16-74identification as a gay or bisexual man2.5%

In the previous wave of the American study, from 2015-2017, 7.0% of respondents in the same age bracket reported ever having sexual contact with a man in their life. This percentage therefore remains at a similar level. In the last twelve months (2017-2019 wave), sexual activity with a man was reported by 3.2% of all men aged 18-49. This is lower than the 7.3% with lifetime experience, meaning some men have had such contact in the past but did not report it over the last year. The study does not state the reason.

The Natsal study separately analyzes kissing and touching without genital contact - such experiences were reported by another 2.4% of men. Altogether, this gives 7.9% of respondents who have had some form of intimate contact with another man.

When researchers narrow the analysis to genital contacts within the last five years, 28% of these men still identify as "heterosexual." This means that the more recent the experience, the less frequently it is accompanied by an exclusively heterosexual label, yet one time never defines the orientation of the respondent. Even a longer episode does not assign it automatically, as its occurrence may be influenced by more factors, such as availability or social pressure, rather than sexual orientation alone.

The same American study (combined data from 2015-2019) asks men aged 18-49 about the direction of their sexual attraction:

Direction of attractionPercentage of men
only to the opposite sex90.6%
mostly to the opposite sex4.7%
equally to both sexes1.1%
mostly to the same sex0.8%
only to the same sex1.9%
not sure0.9%

The largest group outside of those declaring attraction exclusively to women consists of men feeling desire mostly toward the opposite sex (4.7%). Attraction exclusively to men is indicated by 1.9% of respondents. Between these two poles lies an entire spectrum of responses that do not require immediately adopting a specific label.

Desire, Experience, and Identity

AIYoung man watching a gay scene on his phone and nervously biting his nails

The American Psychological Association defines sexual orientation as an enduring pattern of emotional, romantic, or sexual attraction to men, women, or both sexes. In the glossary of terms of this association, orientation is clearly separated from biological sex, gender identity, gender roles, and gender expression. Attraction determines solely who sparks your desire, whereas demeanor relates to how you look, speak, and function on a daily basis.

A research review published by Bailey and colleagues in 2016 in Psychological Science in the Public Interest describes orientation as relative desire directed toward men, women, or both sexes. Choosing a partner for a specific night is a conscious decision regarding behavior, whereas desire itself is not such a decision. You can follow your curiosity, test it in practice, and never return to it again. One night in bed is just behavior - identity stems from an enduring pattern that only emerges once the initial tension fades.

The middle of the orientation spectrum is also a real phenomenon, rather than merely a "waiting room" before a final declaration. In 2020, Jabbour's research team analyzed eight laboratory studies from the US, the UK, and Canada, covering between 474 and 588 cisgender men (depending on whether physiological arousal or subjective reporting was measured). Men identifying as bisexual exhibited a distinctly more bisexual arousal pattern than exclusively heterosexual and exclusively homosexual men. These findings were confirmed by both genital response measurements and participants' self-reports, and the paper was published in the prestigious journal PNAS.

The experience of a single night is not equivalent to a score on the Kinsey scale. That scale describes a long-term, recurring pattern of attraction, not a single evening driven by curiosity and a willingness to try. Satisfaction from intimacy with one man merely opens a certain door, without permanently signing anyone up for any category.

Masculinity Does Not Come Packaged with Heterosexuality

The fear of a first time with a man rarely concerns the physical act itself. Much more often, it is tied to the worry that after such an experience you will become "less masculine." However, sexual orientation does not take away anyone's masculinity.

A man who is attracted to other men remains the exact same person he sees in the mirror. He has the same build, the same job, and the same mannerisms he had before. Gay and bisexual men can be just as masculine in their voice, handshake, and everyday behavior as heterosexual men. They can also be more subtle - just like some men who are interested exclusively in women. None of these traits are a side effect of a single experience.

Additionally, it is worth mentioning that fully heterosexual men in relationships with women surprisingly often find sexual pleasure in wearing women's clothes and the "sissy" fetish. Hence, sexual attraction to a given sex should not be linked to a tendency toward effeminacy.

On Monday after the encounter, you return to your daily duties and your own life. You can tell a close friend about the gay experience, or you can just as well keep it entirely to yourself. Discretion is a standard condition worth clearly agreeing upon in a message even before the date. Your relationships, family, or lifestyle will only change if you decide so yourself.

How to Start When Fear Is Stronger Than Curiosity

The first intimate encounter with a man is meant to test only one thing: whether your body responds to this specific touch and this specific person. It is neither a life exam nor an audition for a new identity.

Anal sex is not a mandatory part of a first time. Kissing, touching with hands, and oral sex constitute a complete, fulfilling experience. A huge portion of stress comes from the misconception that a first encounter must end in penetration. That is not the case at all. If kissing alone does not bring you pleasure, you have every right to stop right there - that is also an important and valuable answer.

Even before meeting, it is worth sending a simple, direct message: "This is my first time with a man. I might have doubts and stop along the way. Please be understanding and don't push when I say stop." A partner who downplays these words or tries to rush things is disqualified even before having coffee together. For your first time, never judge solely by the other person's looks - prioritize understanding, experience, self-confidence, and respect for your boundaries.

Anxiety usually has two sources. The first concerns identity and a sense of masculinity - those fears are effectively dispelled by the studies cited earlier. The second relates to health and the fear of pain. Here, simply "working up the courage" is not enough. Safety and comfort are ensured by a calm conversation, a gentle pace, as well as a condom and proper lubricant, if you decide to have sex at all.

What Kind of Partner to Look for on Your First Time?

AIYoung man looking straight into his lover's eyes, gently held by the face

A successful first time requires the right person, not a random individual chosen "just to test the waters." When looking for a partner, pay attention to several key points:

  • Experience and empathy - choose someone who already has experience in relations with men and knows how to respect your concerns.
  • Similar age - a large age gap during a first experience easily turns into subtle dominance, even if the other party has no bad intentions.
  • Meeting in a public place - don't worry, absolutely no passersby will think you're meeting up for a gay date. You can find more practical tips in our guide to safe online dating.
  • Complete sobriety - drinking alcohol "for courage" drowns out signals coming from the body and natural reactions. We strongly recommend abstaining from intoxicants on your first time.
  • Mutual attraction - follow natural desire. A lack of arousal or bodily indifference is just as valuable information as excitement.
  • Clearly established boundaries - agree in advance on what is an open option and what is definitely off the table. Gentle persuasion on the spot is okay, but if the other person pushes hard and you don't feel safe - it is easier to say "no" after rules have been set beforehand.

If you want to prepare well for an intimate encounter - regardless of your partner's gender - also check out our guide to a first erotic date.

Where to Find a Partner for Your First Time?

A darkroom, meaning a room for anonymous sex without talking, and group parties impose their own fast pace. Under high stress, that is the wrong direction - it is hard to calmly exchange three sentences there and sense whether the other person is even capable of slowing down. It is much safer to meet someone with whom you can clearly set boundaries before exchanging addresses.

The desire to engage in anal intercourse in a receptive role does not have to be synonymous with attraction to men either. A man can also successfully take on a submissive role in a heterosexual relationship. The most important thing is to stay true to yourself and never force anything.

When the Clothes Are Already on the Chair

A regular shower is completely sufficient. Elaborate, "pharmacy-grade" preparations, on the other hand, only amplify stress and are not needed at all for kissing and affectionate touch.

During oral sex and hand stimulation, a condom is a sensible choice - especially with a partner you met just a few days earlier. During anal sex, it is an absolute essential, just like lubricant, which should be used generously.

The World Health Organization emphasizes that the anus does not produce enough natural lubrication for anal sex, making ample use of lubricant crucial. Only water-based or silicone-based lubricants are compatible with condoms - other substances can damage the material. Consistent and proper condom use significantly reduces the risk of HIV infection and other sexually transmitted infections (STIs).

The CDC specifies what to avoid with latex: petroleum jelly, dietary fats, mineral oils, massage oils, body lotions, or cooking oil weaken the condom's structure and lead to breakage. Only water or silicone remains a safe choice. A new condom must be used for every act of intercourse, placed on a fully erect penis before any contact with the partner's body. When withdrawing the penis, hold the condom at the base while an erection is still maintained. Breakages result far more often from usage errors (rushing, lack of lubrication, or putting it on inside out) than from a defect in the product itself.

During anal penetration, pain means an immediate stop. A tearing sensation is not a threshold to "wait out." It is a sign of dryness or moving too quickly into actual intercourse. A single word is enough: "stop." A partner who keeps pushing despite this is not the right person either to continue your first time or for any future meeting.

Questions Before Your First Time with a Man

Does one time with a man mean being gay?

No. According to the British Natsal-3 study, as many as 59.5% of men who have experience having sex with another man identify as heterosexual. A label comes from an enduring pattern of attraction, not from a single experimental night.

What if I don't enjoy sex with a man, yet I keep thinking about it?

Indifference or a lack of satisfaction is a completely natural outcome of an experiment. Even if you felt attraction, having an awkward first encounter still does not define your orientation. Think carefully about what went wrong and whether the partner was a good fit for you.

Does a first time with a man have to mean anal sex?

No. Kissing, hand stimulation, or oral sex are completely fulfilling experiences. Anal sex only makes sense when both sides genuinely want it - if you have any doubts, there is no reason to rush into it.

Does attraction to men take away masculinity?

Sexual orientation only determines who sparks your desire. Your character, voice, or daily life remain a completely separate matter. One night does not change who you are or how you function on a daily basis. A man who is attracted to other men is no different from one who is attracted to women.

What kind of partner should I look for when I'm really nervous about my first time?

Ideally someone experienced in relations with men who will agree to meet in a public place first and respect your pace. On the gay and bi dating site on Wink3r, you can openly write about your expectations and find the right person.